Pokémon HeartGold/SoulSilver

Starters

Chikorita

Pros:

• It evolves into Meganium at Level 32, early for a starter Pokémon
• Good defensive stats

Cons:

• Poor offensive movepool
• Poor offensive stats

Overall:

Considered the worst of three starters, due to limited offensive movepool and because many Gym Leaders have advantages for Grass-type Pokémon, making it a very hard difficulty.

Cyndaquil

Pros:

• It evolves into Quilava at Level 14, early for a starter Pokémon
• High Sp. Attack and Speed
• Knows Shadow Claw, Aerial Ace and Solarbeam
• Can double as an HM whore with the below Abra/Kadabra strategy, as it learns Rock Smash, Rock Slide, Strength, and Cut.

Cons:

• Low HP and Defenses makes it a bit difficulty
• Poor special movepool

Overall:

One of useful starter Pokémon despite its limited special movepool. The Johto Gym Leaders have many advantages only a few disadvantages to Fire-type Pokémon.

Totodile

Pros:

• High HP/Attack/Defense
• Evolves for Feraligatr at Level 30, the earliest of 12 starters
• Can double as an HM whore with the below Abra/Kadabra strategy, as it learns Rock Smash, Rock Slide, Strength, and Cut
• Learns Dragon Dance and Swords Dance giving it amazing Attack
• Knows Surf by HM which always nice

Cons:

• Evolves to Croconaw at Level 18, late for a Starter Pokémon
• Its low speed makes Torrent a swepping difficulty